Why we’re not using a crib

Call me crazy.

Don’t worry, my mother already has. And my mother-in-law is too polite to say it to my face, but when she heard our plans, she probably thought it.

From the beginning, Adam and I never liked the idea of a crib. We called it a “baby prison”. There are stories of Adam crawling out of his crib, while I used to slam mine against the wall to get the attention of my parents. Yikes. Could you imagine what our offspring would do to a crib?

We discovered an alternative while reading a book about Montessori and early childhood development. Montessori believed that a baby should sleep on a small bed on the floor in a room that’s been made safe for him. This way, a child can foster his sense of exploration by having the ability to get out of bed and crawl around his room. He can also engage in solo play time, which is as important for baby as it is for Mom.

The floor bed was hard to find. We ended up doing some online research and ordered it through a company in Kentucky that makes Montessori-based furniture. It was a little smaller than we imagined it would be but I think it’s going to work for another few years.

Eli was in a Pack n Play in our bedroom for the first three months, so I guess you could say he’s already been in a crib. But when he was three months old, we transitioned him into his own bedroom on the floor bed. It took him a while to get used to it and to be honest, it was a crapshoot each time he woke up.

Would he be on the bed?

And if he wasn’t on the bed, exactly how far away would he be?

Maybe he’ll sorta kinda be on the bed…?

It’s been five months now and the experiment is still in progress. He’s definitely learned how to stay on the bed and 95% of the time, he’s on the bed in the morning, after 10+ hours of sleep. (I’m lucky, I know.)

Naps are a whole different ballgame and it’sbeen no holds barred now that he’s army crawling around. (Oh yeah, he’s army crawling. HOLY SHIT!) He’ll wake up from his nap and crawl over to the bookcase and start playing with the books, which I think is sort of awesome. He has his space, he can travel around it safely and play with whatever he wants. He’s not locked up in a crib, crying for us to let him out so that he can play. He’s not attempting to crawl out of a crib or falling while in the process.

I tell myself that we’re teaching him how to sleep. Which is something I didn’t expect to have to teach a baby. I thought they just knew how to sleep. But more importantly in my mind, we’re teaching him how to sleep ANYWHERE. Because you never know where you’re going to end up in life. The ability to curl up on the airport floor or a friend’s couch can be a lifesaving skill.

So that’s why we’re not using a crib.

Please call me crazy. It’s what I get for talking about parenting philosophies anyway.

We also have friends that call the floor bed a baby litter box. So you’re probably not going to offend me.

And also? Do you know how much sneaking around I had to do in order to take these pictures while he was napping?

(P.S. I found a few beautiful examples of other parents going the floor bed route.)

  • Steph

    I read the same book you linked and am so happy to have found this post. I've been trying to explain my “crazy” decision to friends and family and it's great to see not only a working example of the child bed, but to also find comments in support of this decision. Thank you.

  • ruth williamson

    hilarious, since we did this for quite some time, and just called it “the mattress on the floor.”

    we, um, didn't actually think about paying for a bed down there.

    i've got 4 kids now, who've slept in pretty much every configuration, and they all turn out about the same: fine.

    you're crazy.  and so am i ;-)

  • http://talltara.com/ tarable

    You're so welcome Steph!

  • Bee

    I put my daughter on a mattress on the floor (at the foot of my bed) at 18 months. She loves it, never really liked her crib. She's still in my bed most nights starting around midnight to 5am.

  • S D

    Could you say where you got the big box frame? I have been looking for something similar without much luck. Probably just not using the right keywords! I want to do the mattress on the floor but would love to prop I up an inch or two since the floors are chilly in winter and I worry about mold on the mattress.

  • http://talltara.com/ tarable

    This is the company in Kentucky that we ordered from:
    http://lordequip.com/ They had a larger size frame but we went with the smaller one. In hindsight, we might have gone larger. Good luck!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=713750579 Michelle Arends

    we tried this and my 11 month old finally sleeps through the night!! thank you!!

  • http://talltara.com/ tarable

    That's great news Michelle! Congrats on the sleep!

  • lus

    yes, you are crazy :) but crazy is great :) i m one of those, too, my mum says :) but only, we start a little bit later, until now, my lil one didnt have her own room.. so she fully crawls when we are getting into it.. for her, the crib is the place to sleep, she never tries to get out, so i m hoping she will take her new ‘bed’ the same way :) wish us luck!

  • HEJVM

    What a great idea. I’m so glad I found it. My daughter keeps waking up when we transfer her to her crib now that its at the bottom. I do have a question – did you have issues with him falling out and hitting his head? Did you have to put anything on the floor?

  • http://talltara.com/ tarable

    Since his bed is actually on the floor, he doesn’t have very far to fall if he does fall out. At the beginning, it was definitely more an issue of him rolling out of the bed. But after a few weeks using the bed, he started to get the hang of it and actually stay in the bed. Hope that helps!

  • kels

    my kids will have to share a room but i like this idea we are thinking of ordering a triple bunk bed i was wondering if you thing one of these would work http://www.bunkloft.com/triple-bunk-beds.html

  • http://talltara.com/ tarable

    That looks awesome! I’ve never seen a triple bunk before.